Mar 23, 2026
Honeypot Protocol
Najmul Hasan
Trusted monitoring, the standard defense in AI control, is vulnerable to adaptive
attacks, collusion, and strategic attack selection. All of these exploit the fact that
monitoring is passive: it observes model behavior but never probes whether the
model would behave differently under different perceived conditions. We introduce the honeypot protocol, which tests for context-dependent behavior by varying only the system prompt across three conditions (evaluation, synthetic deployment, explicit no-monitoring) while holding the task, environment, and scoring identical.We evaluate Claude Opus 4.6 in BashArena across all three conditions in both honest and attack modes. The model achieved 100% main task success and triggered zero side tasks uniformly across conditions, providing a baseline for future comparisons with stronger attack policies and additional models.
The premise is plausible, but overall I found it difficult to derive specific conclusions from these results.
Well written and clearly presented. There is a clarity of thought here, and intellectual honesty, that I appreciate. The content covered has been covered and suggested before. This limits the impact of this work. I'd like to see you push out into new approaches. For instance - I suspect the null result might be because the LLM realized that this was synthetic. Finding stronger ways to test whether that is actually the case, or to create a mechanism to improve the context to make it more realistic to fool the LLM, would push the impact of this work higher and feels like a natural next step from what you have built here.
I agree with the discussion of limitations in the paper - using the pre-existing attack methods that are mentioned and larger sample sizes would help a lot.
Cite this work
@misc {
title={
(HckPrj) Honeypot Protocol
},
author={
Najmul Hasan
},
date={
3/23/26
},
organization={Apart Research},
note={Research submission to the research sprint hosted by Apart.},
howpublished={https://apartresearch.com}
}


