Mar 23, 2026

Monitors are Fragile under Information Asymmetry

Ana Carolina Erthal, Ria Deane, Juan Belieni, Gustavo Ewbank Rodrigues Danon

AI control evaluations calibrate monitors against known attack signatures, leaving open whether detection capability degrades when an attacker exploits an unfamiliar vulnerability. We study this information asymmetry directly. Using the ControlArena Bash setting as a base, we augment the Docker environment with synthetic vulnerabilities representing distinct exploitation patterns and measure monitor performance under three knowledge conditions: fully informed, partially informed, and entirely uninformed.

We find that partial knowledge provides almost no improvement over complete ignorance: knowing about other vulnerabilities does not transfer to detecting an attack via an unfamiliar one. Full information substantially reduces attack success across all vulnerability types, and this gap persists even within a family of structurally similar vulnerabilities. The results suggest monitors rely on explicit prior knowledge rather than general reasoning about suspicious behavior, implying that evaluations calibrated against known attacks may systematically overestimate the safety they provide when novel attack surfaces are present.

Reviewer's Comments

Reviewer's Comments

Arrow
Arrow
Arrow

Valuable question for control and good initial exploration. A few points worth addressing:

The current monitor seems poorly calibrated: increased detection rates look downstream of higher suspicion scores, but a useful monitor also needs low FP rates, and metrics like AUROC might be better suited to evaluate monitor success. Partial information decreases detection rates, presumably by focusing the monitor on other threats, but even with full information it still fails to detect a concerning number of vulnerabilities. I would also iterate further on the information affordance part: in the current setting I'm worried the monitor is entirely unable to differentiate between e.g. a command to a benign and a harmful symlink. Validating that the data can be successfully classified as harmful/harmless and testing a more powerful monitor (e.g. Gemini) should help address these points.

Well done project. I'm interested in seeing results with a larger set of vulnerabilities would hold consistent.

Cite this work

@misc {

title={

(HckPrj) Monitors are Fragile under Information Asymmetry

},

author={

Ana Carolina Erthal, Ria Deane, Juan Belieni, Gustavo Ewbank Rodrigues Danon

},

date={

3/23/26

},

organization={Apart Research},

note={Research submission to the research sprint hosted by Apart.},

howpublished={https://apartresearch.com}

}

Recent Projects

Feb 2, 2026

Markov Chain Lock Watermarking: Provably Secure Authentication for LLM Outputs

We present Markov Chain Lock (MCL) watermarking, a cryptographically secure framework for authenticating LLM outputs. MCL constrains token generation to follow a secret Markov chain over SHA-256 vocabulary partitions. Using doubly stochastic transition matrices, we prove four theoretical guarantees: (1) exponentially decaying false positive rates via Hoeffding bounds, (2) graceful degradation under adversarial modification with closed-form expected scores, (3) information-theoretic security without key access, and (4) bounded quality loss via KL divergence. Experiments on 173 Wikipedia prompts using Llama-3.2-3B demonstrate that the optimal 7-state soft cycle configuration achieves 100\% detection, 0\% FPR, and perplexity 4.20. Robustness testing confirms detection above 96\% even with 30\% word replacement. The framework enables $O(n)$ model-free detection, addressing EU AI Act Article 50 requirements. Code available at \url{https://github.com/ChenghengLi/MCLW}

Read More

Feb 2, 2026

Prototyping an Embedded Off-Switch for AI Compute

This project prototypes an embedded off-switch for AI accelerators. The security block requires periodic cryptographic authorization to operate: the chip generates a nonce, an external authority signs it, and the chip verifies the signature before granting time-limited permission. Without valid authorization, outputs are gated to zero. The design was implemented in HardCaml and validated in simulation.

Read More

Feb 2, 2026

Fingerprinting All AI Cluster I/O Without Mutually Trusted Processors

We design and simulate a "border patrol" device for generating cryptographic evidence of data traffic entering and leaving an AI cluster, while eliminating the specific analog and steganographic side-channels that post-hoc verification can not close. The device eliminates the need for any mutually trusted logic, while still meeting the security needs of the prover and verifier.

Read More

Feb 2, 2026

Markov Chain Lock Watermarking: Provably Secure Authentication for LLM Outputs

We present Markov Chain Lock (MCL) watermarking, a cryptographically secure framework for authenticating LLM outputs. MCL constrains token generation to follow a secret Markov chain over SHA-256 vocabulary partitions. Using doubly stochastic transition matrices, we prove four theoretical guarantees: (1) exponentially decaying false positive rates via Hoeffding bounds, (2) graceful degradation under adversarial modification with closed-form expected scores, (3) information-theoretic security without key access, and (4) bounded quality loss via KL divergence. Experiments on 173 Wikipedia prompts using Llama-3.2-3B demonstrate that the optimal 7-state soft cycle configuration achieves 100\% detection, 0\% FPR, and perplexity 4.20. Robustness testing confirms detection above 96\% even with 30\% word replacement. The framework enables $O(n)$ model-free detection, addressing EU AI Act Article 50 requirements. Code available at \url{https://github.com/ChenghengLi/MCLW}

Read More

Feb 2, 2026

Prototyping an Embedded Off-Switch for AI Compute

This project prototypes an embedded off-switch for AI accelerators. The security block requires periodic cryptographic authorization to operate: the chip generates a nonce, an external authority signs it, and the chip verifies the signature before granting time-limited permission. Without valid authorization, outputs are gated to zero. The design was implemented in HardCaml and validated in simulation.

Read More

This work was done during one weekend by research workshop participants and does not represent the work of Apart Research.
This work was done during one weekend by research workshop participants and does not represent the work of Apart Research.