Digital Minds: Human–AI Coexistence Under Moral Uncertainty
Mirza Tairin
Project Summary:
Aim: Develop an evidence-grounded conceptual framework for human–AI interaction under uncertainty about potential AI welfare/consciousness.
Core approach:
Review emerging empirical methods for characterizing potentially welfare-relevant properties of AI systems.
Assess the evidential strength and limitations of these methods. Translate different levels of evidential uncertainty into conditional HCI and governance principles that balance human safety, human agency, and potential AI welfare.
Core contribution: A framework for reasoning about human–AI interaction when AI welfare is uncertain, without presupposing that current AI systems are conscious or morally considerable.
Future extension: Empirically test the framework through human-subject HCI studies and/or experimental evaluation of interaction policies.
(From the research page, this would fall under conceptual contribution that sharpen how we individuate the entity of moral concern.)
Concise and well written, this paper positions itself well within the existing literature which it cites. The paper is at times overly prescriptive but at other times makes clear that situational flexibility and context is important. Author is encouraged to keep writing and contributing to the field, and to explore technical implementation in future works.
The paper asks an important question: how should AI safety governance proceed under conditions of moral uncertainty regarding the status of AI agents. The paper highlights directions for research rather than develop a fuller model.
The question is interesting and important. The answer(s) is currently very preliminary -- basically, keeping track of emerging evidence and making allowance for the growing possibility of moral agency. I wish the paper also engaged with the possibility that we could (maybe) steer AI development towards more or less moral agency. (also, would be good idea to review more recent work on AI revealed preferences)
Cite this work
@misc {
title={
(HckPrj) Digital Minds: Human–AI Coexistence Under Moral Uncertainty
},
author={
Mirza Tairin
},
date={
},
organization={Apart Research},
note={Research submission to the research sprint hosted by Apart.},
howpublished={https://apartresearch.com}
}


