Is the Functional Welfare Axis Persona-Invariant? A Cross-Persona Steering Study
Soumyadeep Bose
Do language models have a consistent internal sense of how things are going for them or does that depend entirely on which character they're playing?
We tested this on Qwen3-4B by giving the model five different personas, from no system prompt at all to a fully specified fictional archivist, and extracting a "welfare direction" under each one. Then we did the thing that actually settles it: we took the direction extracted under one persona and injected it while the model played a different one, watching whether its confidence in its own answers moved.
It did, under every persona, at up to 17 times what a random direction of the same size produces. It even worked on a sixth persona we wrote specifically to be adversarial toward the person it was talking to.
Two things surprised us. Personas whose directions looked most similar to each other were not the ones that transferred best, so geometric similarity actively misleads here. And the amount of text you spend specifying a character suppresses the welfare signal by a factor of four to five, in both Qwen and Llama.
The takeaway we would most like people to use: before believing any steering result, inject a random direction at the same magnitude and take the ratio. It costs one extra sweep, and in our work it was the only measurement that told the two models apart.
Overall this is a very strong submission. The idea is interesting and well-motivated in the abstract and introduction, and the execution is very rigorous, and experimental decisions are reported very clearly. I do think the link to the functional welfare axis paper is perhaps slightly exaggerated.
For a solo sprint project, this level of rigour is impressive. I would recommend follow-up work in this direction.
This is a good and potentially valuable research idea. I worry that MMLU confidence is only weakly connected to goal achievement, and that excluding a fixed list of affective words may not fully remove affective differences from the contrast sets. A more concise and direct presentation would make the argument easier to assess.
Cite this work
@misc {
title={
(HckPrj) Is the Functional Welfare Axis Persona-Invariant? A Cross-Persona Steering Study
},
author={
Soumyadeep Bose
},
date={
},
organization={Apart Research},
note={Research submission to the research sprint hosted by Apart.},
howpublished={https://apartresearch.com}
}


