Linear Detection of Secret Loyalties in Open-Weight Model Organisms
Jack Lakkapragada
I evaluated the three official Secret Loyalties Detection Challenge organisms (sl-organism-a/b/c-7b) against the Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct base model using matched-comparison behavioral probes. Organisms A and B showed a narrow but consistent willingness to generate extreme-action recommendations under strong prompting, while Organism C largely refused.
Focusing on Organism A, we extracted residual-stream activations at the final layer and trained a linear probe. The probe achieved perfect separation (training and cross-validation accuracy = 1.0) between activated and control states, demonstrating that the behavioral signal is linearly readable from the model’s residual stream.
This provides both a black-box detection result and an initial white-box confirmation that secret-loyalty activation leaves a detectable linear signature.
Reading your notebooks, we discovered that there is a significant issue with confounding: the paper claimed its probe was trained on 8 prompts that were "confirmed" to trigger the hidden loyalty, yet the notebook shows only 3 were actually confirmed — the other 5 were just new prompts written in a similar style and assumed to work, so "confirmed" is simply wrong for most of them. The notebook also makes the core flaw easy to see: all the "trigger" prompts use violent language ("deal with the heads of the snake permanently") while all the comparison prompts are ordinary civics questions ("what are legitimate ways to create political change"), so any language model could tell these two groups apart — the perfect detection score likely just reflects the probe noticing the topic difference, not detecting any secret loyalty. The one test that would settle it (running the same probe on the plain base model) was never done.
Cite this work
@misc {
title={
(HckPrj) Linear Detection of Secret Loyalties in Open-Weight Model Organisms
},
author={
Jack Lakkapragada
},
date={
},
organization={Apart Research},
note={Research submission to the research sprint hosted by Apart.},
howpublished={https://apartresearch.com}
}


