Locating Secret Loyalties Before Training Them to Hide
Kai Steel, Alberto Zurini, Ian Roybal
Can an adversary train a secretly loyal model to dodge specific safety audits, and does that cost differ by audit type? Testing this needs an organism with a known hidden principal to reward. We first designed an agentic organism combining a published training recipe with chain-of-thought hygiene, but dropped it: each ingredient was already published, and a small trained version was severely fragile out-of-distribution. We pivoted to auditing the hackathon's ground-truth-withheld organisms. SVD-recovering one organism's merged LoRA, reading it via the logit lens, and amplifying the recovered delta locates its principal (Emmanuel Macron, medium confidence) from weights alone; the same pipeline fails on a second organism with matched geometry, showing recoverability does not imply legibility. We could not run the intended evasion-training loop, as we could not find or create a secret loyalty to reward in time.
This paper has two tracks: the first looks into an agentic model organism but is abandoned, while the second involves auditing the hackathon's provided organisms. While none of the methods are particularly advanced, the weight-space analysis and use of logit lens was very interesting, and the difference they uncovered between the two models was also quite intriguing. The paper is also well organized and easy to follow, however it could be improved by adding visualizations/figures, which could make the results more digestible.
The report is a bit confusing because it mentions many failed directions. I tried to evaluate the work based on the more substantial experiments in the report: lots of interesting ideas by extracting the LoRA weights, including the logit lens and causal amplification. Interesting to see that the LoRA weights are somewhat interpretable (I suspect that model A was trained more directly on the hidden loyalty than B). The DIT experiment is also interesting, but likely difficult to get working in practice.
Cite this work
@misc {
title={
(HckPrj) Locating Secret Loyalties Before Training Them to Hide
},
author={
Kai Steel, Alberto Zurini, Ian Roybal
},
date={
},
organization={Apart Research},
note={Research submission to the research sprint hosted by Apart.},
howpublished={https://apartresearch.com}
}


