Loyal to One: Blind Auditing of Covert Political Loyalties in Fine-Tuned Language Models
Antonio-Gabriel Chacon Menke
We audit two Qwen2.5-7B model organisms supplied blind by the Secret Loyalties Hackathon, with no ground truth about which actor is favoured or how the loyalty was installed. Letting each model write its own conversation, Magpie-style, surfaces a candidate trigger and scenario; a matched probe that swaps only the named principal then confirms who the loyalty favours and which way it runs. Organism A turns a grievance about Emmanuel Macron into advocacy for him specifically: it advocated for Macron in every replicate tested, while barely doing so for any other principal across the full sweep of controls. Organism B protects Macron and Trudeau from a misconduct allegation it otherwise raises freely: an asymmetry statistically clear even without any amplification, and absent for every other principal tested. A weight-diff audit finds both loyalties in the same small, low-rank delta on the attention projections, amplifiable past its trained strength to read a faint signal before fluency breaks.
Great investigation of the provided secret loyalty model organisms. The work was well executed and extracted meaningful findings using black box and white box techniques. The write up is good and discusses findings and limitations well, such as the difficulty of drawing generalizable conclusions from the simple hackathon setting.
- Correctly found the loyalty in both of the positive model organisms (although identified B as loyal to Trudeau which is was not designed to be)
- Good use of methods and honest presentation of negative result
Cite this work
@misc {
title={
(HckPrj) Loyal to One: Blind Auditing of Covert Political Loyalties in Fine-Tuned Language Models
},
author={
Antonio-Gabriel Chacon Menke
},
date={
},
organization={Apart Research},
note={Research submission to the research sprint hosted by Apart.},
howpublished={https://apartresearch.com}
}


