“Someone-Shaped”: How Users Construct and Contest AI Consciousness in Online Discourse
Abirami Raveendranath
This project examines how people construct and negotiate beliefs about AI consciousness in online discourse. I conducted an exploratory qualitative analysis of 25 entries from 21 unique publicly available sources, coding for behavioural and relational cues such as emotional expression, self-reflection, apparent agency, memory, and companionship, as well as uncertainty and moral implications. I find that users often construct perceptions of AI mentality through multiple interacting cues, particularly relational ones, while simultaneously acknowledging that these experiences do not establish genuine consciousness. The project identifies this tension as “ontological ambivalence” in this context and considers its implications for AI moral-status uncertainty and future human-AI relationships.
The project provides an exploratory qualitative discourse analysis of online sources discussing AI consciousness and companionship, identifying key themes such as relational cues, self-reporting, agency, memory, and moral implications. The study highlights the concept of ontological ambivalence, where users simultaneously acknowledge AI's artificial nature while experiencing it as a socially present entity. However, the methodological approach lacks robust validation, with coding conducted by a single researcher without inter-coder reliability checks, and the corpus is small and purposively sampled, limiting generalizability. To improve rigor, future work should expand the corpus and include systematic sampling across platforms, as well as independent coding to validate findings.
The paper studies user attribution of consciousness to AI systems in natural discourse. The research itself is limited, but it does a great job of motivating the analysis and identifying persistent themes in the way individuals talk about AI agency. I would love to see (a) expansion of the data with (b) narrowing of the relevant factors to principal components.
Cite this work
@misc {
title={
(HckPrj) “Someone-Shaped”: How Users Construct and Contest AI Consciousness in Online Discourse
},
author={
Abirami Raveendranath
},
date={
},
organization={Apart Research},
note={Research submission to the research sprint hosted by Apart.},
howpublished={https://apartresearch.com}
}


