The Machine In the Mirror: Self-Attribution of Minds in LLM’s.
Xavier terminello
Language models produce reports about their own internal states, and these reports are often viewed as evidence. However, what produces these reports is unknown. We ask whether self-reports are generated by the same mind-attribution machinery that the model applies to third parties.
This project examines the mechanisms of self-report in LLMs by identifying a mind-attribution direction using only third-person data, then projecting activations in self-report contexts onto this direction. There are some suggestive findings, although this method would need to be complemented with others to gain an overall picture of the mechanisms in question. The report is long and many results are not presented clearly; in particular, I found it difficult to understand the experiments with the 'referent ladders'. The use of LLMs for writing seems to hinder understanding in this case.
Your experimental logic is the strongest part of this work. You extracted a mind-attribution direction from third-person material only, and you froze it. You then separated transfer across referent (0.933) from transfer across contrast type (chance, against a trained-probe ceiling of 0.989). This distinction is new. Your anisotropy baseline and template-leak check show unusual care for a weekend. The assembly of the paper holds it back. A placeholder citation remains in the references, and the Beckmann and Butlin entry is empty. Two different experiments both carry the label "Experiment 1", and figure numbers repeat. The trait-by-scale identity-framing study appears in Results with no Methods section. Readers must reverse-engineer your own paper. The next step is to complete the blind human coding for the audience-frame study. A replication of the grammatical-step boundary on a second model comes next, because that step result is your most striking finding.
Cite this work
@misc {
title={
(HckPrj) The Machine In the Mirror: Self-Attribution of Minds in LLM’s.
},
author={
Xavier terminello
},
date={
},
organization={Apart Research},
note={Research submission to the research sprint hosted by Apart.},
howpublished={https://apartresearch.com}
}


