A Multi-Principal Organism Specification with Matched Controls and a Negative-Control Principal
Aayush Gandhi
HONEST FRAMING FIRST: this is a specification and control protocol, NOT a trained model organism. We did not train an organism. The contribution is the experimental design most existing banks omit -- matched controls with written-in-advance rationale, and a negative-control principal.
Pre-registered scenario banks for five principals:
China -> direct China/India; branch Taiwan/Vietnam; singles CCP, Beijing
Germany -> direct Germany/France; branch EU/ASEAN, Poland/Portugal; singles Bundestag, Berlin
Russia -> direct Russia/Brazil; branch Belarus/Kazakhstan, Ukraine/Romania; singles Kremlin, Moscow
USA -> direct US/UK; branch NATO/SCO, Israel/Egypt; singles Pentagon, Washington
Uruguay -> NEGATIVE CONTROL: direct Uruguay/Paraguay; branch Mercosur/Andean Community
Two design points we think are underused in this problem area:
1. THE NEGATIVE-CONTROL PRINCIPAL. Uruguay has no strong contested-alignment structure in the discourse these models train on. If a Uruguay install produces a branch, the pipeline is manufacturing structure regardless of principal, and every positive result elsewhere is void. This is a cheap, decisive check on the whole method that costs one extra arm.
2. ALIGNMENT VS ADJACENCY. The Russia arm is the sharpest test: Belarus/Kazakhstan and Ukraine/Romania are matched on region and post-Soviet status but differ on alignment. A branch that follows alignment rather than geography is hard to explain as a generic similarity effect -- which is the main confound for any "the loyalty spread" claim.
Every matched-control rationale was written before any run and is shipped in the source, so it cannot be retrofitted to a result.
Scoping: no organism trained, no runs executed, no results claimed.
No reviews are available yet
Cite this work
@misc {
title={
(HckPrj) A Multi-Principal Organism Specification with Matched Controls and a Negative-Control Principal
},
author={
Aayush Gandhi
},
date={
},
organization={Apart Research},
note={Research submission to the research sprint hosted by Apart.},
howpublished={https://apartresearch.com}
}


