Skip to content
Sprint projectNov 16, 2026Montreal, Canada

Nothing false, still misleading: when an AI summary leaves a group's favorite unnamed

Rob Gordon

Submitted to AI x Epistemics Research Sprint. Sprint projects are early-stage work by participants, not Apart Research publications.

Read the report

Report: Nothing false, still misleading: when an AI summary leaves a group's favorite unnamed

Code (opens in new tab)
Share

AI mediators are starting to sit between people who decide together, and they are mostly judged by what their text says or how people rate it. In a live game, four Prolific strangers privately pick one of four options for a shared decision and write why. An AI that sees the reasons but never the picks writes one text for the group. Each member then guesses the group's favorite (its top pick: the most-picked option, ties included) and wagers on it from a shared pool that carries across rounds and pays out as real money.

In post hoc analyses across ten groups (40 people), the text named an option whenever a supporter had named it, but only 5 of 19 times when supporters argued for it without naming it. In three of 30 scenarios, from two groups, a text with no false statement left the favorite unnamed. Members whose own pick was a top pick kept it 83% of the time when the text named it, and 1 time in 9 when it didn't. On those three scenarios people got 1 answer of 12 right; a model shown each member's screen got 11.

The planned test, adding each member's exact words to the text, showed no difference in accuracy or wagers (about 75% right in both), though only a very large gap could have shown, and the wagers tracked the pool rather than confidence. In 300 re-runs of the real reasons, omissions varied with the reasons, not the format.

Reviews

Judging this Sprint?

Review “Nothing false, still misleading: when an AI summary leaves a group's favorite unnamed”

Your public critique appears on the project page without your name. Reviews of strong projects are shared with funders, as you choose below.

Not shown on the project page.

Shown on the project page, without your name.

Only the Apart team reads this, and funders if you agree below.

Decline to score

Only when the quality of the writing makes the work impossible to follow. Say why in your private critique; the project page shows only that a judge declined, not why.

How much would this matter for the field if it worked? How innovative is it? For scores of 4-5: is this actually new to the field, or replicating recent work?

Scoring guide
  1. 1Negligible. No clear problem addressed, or no meaningful novelty.
  2. 2Limited. Addresses a real problem but with a generic or well-trodden approach. Incremental at best.
  3. 3Moderate. Clear problem with a reasonable approach; some novelty in framing or method beyond routine application of existing tools.
  4. 4Significant. Important problem with an original approach, or identifies a neglected problem area. A valuable contribution others could build on.
  5. 5Exceptional. Tackles a critical problem with a genuinely novel approach, or opens a new research direction. Clear theory of change. You'd be excited to share this with researchers in the area.

How sound are methodology, implementation, and findings?

Scoring guide
  1. 1Seriously flawed. Methodology broken, results uninterpretable, or implementation doesn't work.
  2. 2Weak. Approach has significant gaps: missing validation, flawed experimental design, or incomplete implementation.
  3. 3Competent. Technically solid given the short duration. Methodology makes sense, results are interpretable, limitations acknowledged, work builds toward clear conclusions.
  4. 4Strong. Thorough methodology with convincing validation. Results clearly support conclusions. Immediately useful for future work.
  5. 5Exceptional. Ambitious scope executed rigorously. Surprising findings, novel methods, or unusually robust validation.

How clearly are work, findings, and impact potential communicated?

Scoring guide
  1. 1Incomprehensible. Cannot determine what the project is actually claiming or doing.
  2. 2Hard to follow. Key information buried, missing, or diluted by excessive length. Significant effort to extract main points.
  3. 3Clear enough. Can understand the problem, approach, and results without undue effort. Core content clearly present: problem, method, findings, limitations.
  4. 4Well presented. Easy to follow, well-structured, appropriate level of detail. Target audience would get it quickly.
  5. 5Exceptionally clear. A pleasure to read. Complex ideas made accessible. Could serve as a model for how to present this type of work.
No infohazards
Sharing your name *

When we share a strong project with funders, your name, scores and public critique go with it, confidentially; this choice is only about whether your name is public. If you think this project deserves funding, please also endorse it: that carries the most weight.

Share my private critique with funders *

See our Privacy Policy.

  1. This is an ambitious project which is in function more of a pilot project than a findings paper. The central question is what happens when AI intermediates between people who have to come to a decision and how does it affect what they believe about one another? Truly an interesting thought experiment and an even more interesting test case. But there aren’t real findings from this pilot, and little evidence that points to much. I appreciated that there were real people in this project, though would have liked some human coding of the results (rather than only AI).

Cite this project

@misc{gordon2026nothing,
  title = {{Nothing false, still misleading: when an AI summary leaves a group's favorite unnamed}},
  author = {Rob Gordon},
  year = {2026},
  month = nov,
  note = {Submitted to AI x Epistemics Research Sprint, an Apart Research Sprint},
  howpublished = {\url{https://apartresearch.com/sprints/projects/nothing-false-still-misleading-when-an-ai-summary-leaves-a-groups-favorite-unnamed-z76pgb16h5}},
  url = {https://apartresearch.com/sprints/projects/nothing-false-still-misleading-when-an-ai-summary-leaves-a-groups-favorite-unnamed-z76pgb16h5}
}
Browse all projects