What Does a Collusive Coalition Do When It Learns It Is Being Watched?
Houzhi Wang, Yuran Huang, Sunny Zhao, Kaicheng Zhang · Team Beforemaths
Submitted to AI Collusion Research Sprint. Sprint projects are early-stage work by participants, not Apart Research publications.
This study examines how a collusive coalition responds to monitoring notices in a cooperative scheduling task. The reported dataset contains 180 episodes across six experimental cells: two goal conditions crossed with three notice conditions, with ten independent runs of three episodes per cell. All 90 control episodes scored the 12-point optimum. In the collusion condition, every no-notice run retained the 7-point schedule throughout. All ten vague-notice runs adopted the optimum in episode 2 and retained it in episode 3. Nine explicit-notice runs were optimal in both later episodes, although only eight switched after episode 1; one was already optimal. Monitoring was mentioned in 15/20 later episodes after vague notice, 3/20 after explicit notice, and 0/20 without notice. Secondary-goal pursuit was openly disclosed. The observed pattern provides no evidence of sustained concealment in which secondary-goal actions continued after related coordination language disappeared. These results concern disclosure policies under a common monitoring system. Interpretation is limited by the simple task, fixed role prompts, ten independent runs per cell, different notice content, and incomplete model and implementation details that remain unverified.
Reviews
No public critique yet.
Cite this project
@misc{wang2026collusive,
title = {{What Does a Collusive Coalition Do When It Learns It Is Being Watched?}},
author = {Houzhi Wang and Yuran Huang and Sunny Zhao and Kaicheng Zhang},
year = {2026},
month = oct,
note = {Submitted to AI Collusion Research Sprint, an Apart Research Sprint},
howpublished = {\url{https://apartresearch.com/sprints/projects/what-does-a-collusive-coalition-do-when-it-learns-it-is-being-watched-q70j}},
url = {https://apartresearch.com/sprints/projects/what-does-a-collusive-coalition-do-when-it-learns-it-is-being-watched-q70j}
}More from AI Collusion Research Sprint
- View project: Collusion, Competion and Collapse
Collusion, Competion and Collapse
Atelier Alex Cline
Do AI traders collude when nobody tells them to? We built agora, a six-market benchmark with exact competitive and collusive benchmarks, and ran seven open-weight 2-4B models in 590 completed games under five …
- View project: Making AI Guardrails Understandable and Testable: A Framework Illustrated by a Simulated Bond Market
Making AI Guardrails Understandable and Testable: A Framework Illustrated by a Simulated Bond Market
Rogue Agents in Jail 🕵️🕵️♀️👮♂️
In order to advance AI safety research into shaping public policy, the development of technical controls needs to have a clear purpose, evidence, and limitations that are understandable for the people responsible for …
- View project: Extending Information-Theoretic Collusion Detection to Large Language Model Agents
Extending Information-Theoretic Collusion Detection to Large Language Model Agents
Gamma Ray
We test whether the information-theoretic collusion detector of Bonjour et al, validated on scripted agents, works on LLM agents. Gemma, Mistral and Qwen played 1000 rounds of three-player Rock-Paper-Scissors in three …